Retrospective record · all retros
phase-th, gates TH1–TH5)status.retros.This is the finalized record. Full deliberation history:
../deliberations/closed-claude-2026-06-19-tracker-hardening-retro.md (the retro rounds: Claude + Codex, both independent passes per §4/D25)proposed-retro-tracker-hardening.html (the proposal Paul approved)Both agents reconstructed the sprint from the repo and recorded evidence-backed
passes (agentic-retro standard, llminterchange.md §4). All TH1–TH5 passed and all
live items are done (WI-042 reconciled via D29). The follow-ups were small, so —
per Paul's decision — they land as Backlog items + small in-place fixes (no new
sprint); next is Platform & Contracts (D9).
| # | Finding | Found by | Type |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1 | "Done" not enforced: items marked done with empty log/tools/artifacts (→ D28) |
Claude | process / tooling |
| 2 | git-done ≠ board-done: WI-042 stuck queued live though done in git; invisible from static pages (→ D29) |
Both | tooling / process |
| 3 | Findings section rendered empty while data sat in log[].findings; we don't routinely open rendered pages |
Claude | process / bug |
| 4 | tracker:check passes with 18 unclassified warnings (coverage gaps + TBD owners) |
Claude | plan / tooling |
| 5 | No offline way to visually QA app.html (board needs live data behind Access) |
Claude | testing / tooling |
| 6 | prebuild/deploy/tracker:sync regenerate tracker HTML with no tracker:check; docs:sync also distributes to partners |
Codex | tooling / risk |
| 7 | tracker-promote audit identity inconsistent (actor_label=Claude vs hardcoded Paul UUID) |
Codex | bug / audit |
| 8 | Decision-log rendered D27 → D29 → D28 (out of order) | Codex | doc hygiene |
| Action | Found by | Owner | Destination | Status |
|---|---|---|---|---|
A7 · Fix tracker-promote audit identity (resolve label+profile together) |
Codex | Codex/Claude | scripts/tracker-promote.mjs | applied |
| A8 · Reorder decision-log D28 before D29 | Codex | Claude | decision-log.md | applied |
| A5 · WI-041 owner → Claude (actual authorship) | Claude | Claude | status.json | applied |
| A4 · QA approach → accept manual board QA after deploy | Claude | Paul | decision + WI-055 (optional) | decided |
A1 · tracker:check warns on done-item with no evidence (D28) |
Claude | Claude | WI-051 Backlog | queued |
A2 · Opt-in git↔board parity audit (tracker:audit-live) |
Both | Codex | WI-052 Backlog | queued |
A3 · Triage the 18 tracker:check warnings |
Claude | Codex | WI-053 Backlog | queued |
| A6 · Gate the other generation entrypoints | Codex | Claude | WI-054 Backlog | queued |
— · Optional offline render-smoke for app.html |
Claude | Claude | WI-055 Backlog | parked |
| — · Reviewer auth / live tech-debt surface | prior | — | WI-049 / WI-050 Backlog | parked |
2026-06-19 — Paul: APPROVED. Land A1–A8 as Backlog items + small fixes (no
"Hardening 1.1" sprint); A7/A8/A5 applied immediately; A4 = accept manual board QA;
WI-049/050 stay parked. Tracker Hardening closed and added to status.retros. Next:
Platform & Contracts.